Pumpkin spice does not belong exclusively to the coffee crowd. Bigelow has a whole little fall lineup for the tea kettle, including Salted Caramel, Pumpkin Spice, Simply Cinnamon Apple and Cranberry Harvest.
But before you pick the cutest box, there are two details worth checking: which ones have caffeine, and how many boxes you are actually ordering. That second part matters if you want a cozy cup, not a pantry takeover.
Two fall flavors are black tea. Two are caffeine-free.
The flavor names alone do not tell the whole story. Pumpkin Spice and Salted Caramel use black tea; Simply Cinnamon Apple and Cranberry Harvest are herbal blends that Bigelow identifies as caffeine-free.
| Tea | Caffeine choice | Bigelow’s flavor description, in plain English |
|---|---|---|
| Pumpkin Spice | Black tea; contains caffeine | Pumpkin and warm spices |
| Salted Caramel | Black tea; contains caffeine | Caramel with a little salt |
| Simply Cinnamon Apple | Caffeine-free herbal tea | Apple and cinnamon |
| Cranberry Harvest | Caffeine-free herbal tea | Tart cranberry and cinnamon |
If skipping caffeine is your deciding factor, that narrows this particular lineup to apple or cranberry. If you want the black-tea base, your choice is pumpkin spice versus caramel. There is no need to order all four just to figure out which side of that split you want.
The $23.95 listing is for six boxes—not one
As checked September 18, 2026, each of these four listings on Bigelow’s site shows $23.95 for six 18-count boxes. That is 108 tea bags of the selected flavor, not a mixed four-flavor sampler.
Before shipping, taxes or any checkout discount, the math works out to about $3.99 per box or 22 cents per tea bag. Buying one case of every flavor would mean 24 boxes and 432 bags, with a listed merchandise total of $95.80. A tea-loving household might use that; someone just curious about cranberry probably does not need to start there.
Check the package quantity wherever you buy, and compare the delivered total rather than treating a case price like a single-box price. Prices and availability can change.
Pick the flavor first, then make room for it
For a breakfast cup, the two black-tea choices could sit alongside something savory like these homemade hashbrowns. For a caffeine-free fall option, the apple-versus-cranberry choice is the useful comparison.
You can browse the Bigelow seasonal collection and follow the individual product links above to check the current package and ingredients. Cozy is the goal. Accidentally ordering six boxes when you meant one is optional.
