Skip to Content

Disney Just Released Their Peanut Butter And Jelly Milkshake Recipe And It Takes Just 4 Ingredients

Disney has just released a recipe that will remind you of your favorite childhood lunch!

Courtesy of Disney Parks Blog

That’s right ladies and gentleman, PB and J is back but with a glow up!

With only 4 ingredients, this just might be the simplest recipe Disney has released yet and it is a must try!

Here’s how you make the 50’s themed PB and J Milkshake from Disney’s 50’s Prime Time Café at Disney’s Hollywood Studios.

Ingredients List:

  • 2 tablespoons of Peanut Butter
  • 2 tablespoons of Jelly (Strawberry or Grape)
  • 2 cups of Vanilla Ice Cream
  • 1/4 cup of Milk


  1. Add all of your ingredients together into the blender and blend until smooth.
  2. Add additional Peanut Butter or Jelly to taste.
  3. Two cups of sliced Strawberries can also be substituted for Jelly if preferred!
View this post on Instagram

We’re at Hollywood Studios (MGM Studios) today!! 🎞🎬🎭 • • Today’s #colormeparkhopper post is dedicated to a new favorite sweet treat that Mom and I discovered on our last trip in November. Also I can’t believe it was just in November, sometimes I still feel like I’m waiting for the trip to approach 😅. • • This is the Peanut Butter and Jelly shake from 50s Prime Time Cafe. I had heard about this shake, but honestly had low expectations. It turned out to be warm that afternoon, so mom and I stopped for a quick break in the Tune In lounge – connected to Prime Time but doesn’t require reservations. We ordered just the shake and IT WAS SO GOOD. • • We slurped that baby to the last drop. I would say I’ll recreate it at home, but I know it won’t taste the same. This definitely makes it on my list for every trip to come. • • Have you had the PB&J shake from Prime Time before? Let me know your thoughts! Also!! Who else loves 50s Prime Time Cafe 🙋🏻‍♀️ • • Check out my stories for another Hollywood Studios anecdote about the most magical night ever! • • #mainstreetbelle #disneyblogger #disneyblog #disneybloggers #disneyblogs #disneyblogging #hollywoodstudiosdisney #hollywoodstudiosfood #50sprimetimecafe #peanutbutterandjellyshake #mgmstudiosforever #hollywoodstudiostreats #waltdisneyworldfood #waltdisneyworldsweets

A post shared by Disney Lifestyle | Travel Blog (@mainstreetbelle) on

Now how simple was that, in literally one, two, three, you have your own Disney inspired 50’s themed Peanut Butter and Jelly Milkshake from Hollywood Studios!

As always, you can check out the fill recipe on Disney Parks Blog and don’t forget the whipped cream and cherry on top!

You can also check out a video of it being made below.

Heres How You Can Order A Skinny Tropical Beach Drink at Starbucks
← Previous
You Can Get A Color-Changing Stitch Starbucks-Type Cup and I Need It
Next →