Skip to Content

25 Ooey Gooey Peanut Butter & Jelly Recipes

Everyone knows peanut butter & jelly is for kids. You cut off the crusts, cut it into triangles (or squares, if you’re a monster), and serve it with a glass of milk. But somewhere deep inside all of us is a little kid who doesn’t understand why they can’t have naps anymore. Just because you’re all grown up doesn’t mean you can’t still get excited these 25 ooey gooey peanut butter & jelly recipes. In fact, because you’re an adult you’ll love them more – because peanut butter & jelly isn’t just for sandwiches anymore. Enjoy!

It's peanut butter jelly...recipes...time! And we're not talking sandwiches anymore. These 25 ooey gooey pb&j recipes are nothing like your mom used to make! | #TotallyTheBomb #recipes #peanutbutterjellytime #pb&j #nostalgia #childhood #cupcakes #cake #fudge #bars #dessert #nocrust #cookies #doughnuts #homemade #yum

Ooey Gooey Peanut Butter & Jelly Recipes

1. Delicious pb&j cupcakes are melt in your mouth yumm.

2. If you want to feel fancy, check out these peanut butter & jelly macarons.

3. No need to break out the mixing bowl with this fun peanut butter, jelly, and cream cheese rollups recipe.

4. You’ll never think of pb&j the same way again once you try this peanut butter & jelly pop tart.

5. These gluten-free peanut butter & jelly cookie sandwiches are exactly what you’ve been craving.

It's peanut butter jelly...recipes...time! And we're not talking sandwiches anymore. These 25 ooey gooey pb&j recipes are nothing like your mom used to make! | #TotallyTheBomb #recipes #peanutbutterjellytime #pb&j #nostalgia #childhood #cupcakes #cake #fudge #bars #dessert #nocrust #cookies #doughnuts #homemade #yum

6. Move over Reece’s, it’s time to check out some peanut butter & jelly cups.

7. Who needs nacho seasoning when you can have pb&j popcorn?

8. These gluten-free peanut butter & jelly grain bars will make you feel like a kid, while eating like an adult.

9. Delicious peanut butter & jelly cookies are what milk was made for.

10. Surprise everyone with this incredible peanut butter & jelly layer cake.

It's peanut butter jelly...recipes...time! And we're not talking sandwiches anymore. These 25 ooey gooey pb&j recipes are nothing like your mom used to make! | #TotallyTheBomb #recipes #peanutbutterjellytime #pb&j #nostalgia #childhood #cupcakes #cake #fudge #bars #dessert #nocrust #cookies #doughnuts #homemade #yum

11. Move over pumpkin spice, it’s time for peanut butter & jelly banana bread.

12. No white bread was harmed in the making of these pb&j sandwich cookies.

13. Even the kids will get a kick out of this peanut butter & jelly dip. A perfect after school snack.

14. Pb&j lava cakes are what chocolate lava cakes wanted to be when they were little.

15. These peanut butter & jelly thumbprint cookies will make you never want ‘just’ a peanut butter cookie ever again.

It's peanut butter jelly...recipes...time! And we're not talking sandwiches anymore. These 25 ooey gooey pb&j recipes are nothing like your mom used to make! | #TotallyTheBomb #recipes #peanutbutterjellytime #pb&j #nostalgia #childhood #cupcakes #cake #fudge #bars #dessert #nocrust #cookies #doughnuts #homemade #yum

16. These peanut butter & jelly stuffed doughnuts taste like they’re fresh out of the bakery.

17. Or for a more ‘adult’ snacking treat, check out these vegan pb&j muffins.

18. Cinnamon is out, peanut butter & jelly rolls are the new hot thing.

19. This peanut butter & jelly white chocolate bark is STUFFED with ooey gooey goodness.

20. Homemade pb&j ice cream will have you craving long nights in.

It's peanut butter jelly...recipes...time! And we're not talking sandwiches anymore. These 25 ooey gooey pb&j recipes are nothing like your mom used to make! | #TotallyTheBomb #recipes #peanutbutterjellytime #pb&j #nostalgia #childhood #cupcakes #cake #fudge #bars #dessert #nocrust #cookies #doughnuts #homemade #yum

21. Delicious peanut butter & jelly bars are a take-with-you taste all your friends will wish they had.

22. These pb&j pinwheels are made with flakey crusts and lots of love.

23. Creamy peanut butter & jelly cheesecake will have you slicing off more than you can chew.

24. You’ve never tasted anything quite like this peanut butter & jelly fudge.

25. Amazing peanut butter & jelly shortbread bars don’t have to be eaten with milk – but they prefer to be…

How One Simple Trick Changed My Beauty Routine
← Previous
3-Ingredient Instant Pot Barbecue Pulled Pork
Next →